This post was originally published on July 8, 2015 and has been updated to reflect new opinions.

Primal Pit Paste vs. Nourish Organic

Primal Pit Paste vs. Nourish Organic? Primal Pit Paste was the way to go

When I originally started testing out natural deodorants. I started out by using products that were most similar to the standard anti-perspirant. First, I want a product that has a similar application process to what I’m used to. My second goal is to move away from using products that contain aluminum. I have tried a number of deodorants since my initial switch: Primal Pit Paste, Nourish Organic, Tao Crystals and Piper Wai. More about my experience with each after the jump. 

Primal Pit Paste

I started using Primal Pit Paste in February of 2015. February seemed like a good time to dive into the switch because it would be cooler and I could hopefully adjust to sweating slowly. Every day of the first week I thought about going to the grocery store and picking up my normal antiperspirant. Every. Single. Day. That first week I sweat so much. I had pit stains on my shirts and smelled like I hadn’t showered. It was bad enough that I skipped the gym because I was nervous of how I would smell while working out.

Luckily, I was busy that week and didn’t have the time to swing through the grocery for the old antiperspirant. By the middle of the second week my body had adjusted. I had a mild scent of lavender (the Primal Pit Paste scent I chose) and I was sweating less. I was back in the gym, and I still didn’t smell. It was miraculous. The one down side of the Pit Paste is its availability. I had to buy it online or at Whole Foods, not particularly convenient if you are like me and Whole Foods isn’t your regular market.

Nourish Organic

My second test product happened out of convenience. At the grocery store one day I remembered I was low on deodorant. I checked out the natural options available and Nourish Organic seemed to be the closest thing – I was swayed by the pretty packaging. That plus the fact that it is billed as a natural antiperspirant.

Big mistake. The stick rolls on grainy, like painfully grainy. The primary ingredient in this stick is beeswax, probably to block your pores, but for me it cause some pretty serious irritation. I noticed recently that they have rolled out a gel version of their product which may address some of these problems.

Needless to say, I stopped using it immediately. I went a couple of days without any product on (something that would not have been possible if I had been using my old antiperspirant up until this point) and it cleared up. I decided this was my golden opportunity to try out a deodorant crystal.

Deodorant Crystal

I really enjoyed using the crystal all the way up until it started warming up again. It was very effective in the cooler months. For it to work once the heat started coming back I needed to reapply 4 or 5 times a day. I did find that if I combined the crystal spray and the crystal, it was a little better. I didn’t not like the crystal, and it is super cost-effective, but I decided to keep testing.

Piper Wai

The next experiment was Piper Wai. Piper Wai had been on my radar for a while, but I had been a bit turned off by the idea of applying deodorant with my fingers. I decided it was worth a shot and ordered a container off amazon. Pro tip: always order directly from the Piper Wai website. They were out of stock when I placed my initial order, which is why I went with amazon, but I ended up paying like $8 more for the product. I got over the whole applying the product with your fingers thing after the first use, the stuff is amazing.

Going in, you have to remember that you are going to sweat – this is not an antiperspirant. Sweat does not equal smell, though. What I have learned in the last year of trial and error is that once you have weened your body off antiperspirant it begins to self-regulate better. I am a pretty sweaty person and I rarely have sweat stains anymore (even during the crazy heat waves we had this summer.) Beyond that, I am at the point where the only time my sweat actually smells is if I have been eating poorly. Overall, I give Piper Wai a 5 out of 5. If you are looking for a natural deodorant that is 100% the one I recommend.